The episode starts with the church's living room, where Panty and Stocking are watching TV and eating chips respectively. Panty asks Stocking how far had she gone, yesterday, with a guy who had a bulge in his pants. Stocking answers Panty she had only made out with him, so he wouldn't think she was easy. Stocking glances at her watch, realizing it had been five hours already since Garterbelt told them he was going to make lunch. Panty and Stocking keep talking about how Garterbelt even put a sign outside the kitchen door, which reads "No Angels Allowed".
Chuck comes carrying a plate of a dough-looking mix, and starts dancing. Panty asks Stocking to give her some of her chips, but her hand gets stuck inside the container. Panty tries freeing her hand, but upon doing so, she falls outside the window. Meanwhile, Stocking orders Hop Whip White Baumkuchen after seeing an offer on TV, shortly after Panty comes back telling Stocking she has an idea to get back to Heaven. She proceeds to explain her idea of using a pole to go to space, but Stocking tells her she likes being on Earth and asks Panty if she feels the same way. Panty confesses men on Earth are okay, but she also assures they were taking a dip.
Their stomachs suddenly begin to growl and Stocking starts complaining, saying that she feels sad whenever she is hungry. After having a small argument with her sister, Stocking grabs the pole Panty brought earlier and goes towards the kitchen to tell Garterbelt to hurry up. Chuck comes once again carrying his food plate, and starts eating after dancing. Stocking then comes back in the room, with a huge bump on her head. Panty asks her sister if she wants to order pizza, and the two of them start ordering a bunch of different types of food on the phone. Panty tells Stocking they should go to the night club tonight too, in order to fuck like rabbits.
Then the doorbell rings and the Anarchy sisters go to answer the door, thinking it would be some of the food they ordered, but it turns out to be Brief. Brief asks them where the party was, but the angels tell him there was no party. Brief tries to talk to them, but the Anarchy sisters kill the conversation every time. Brief assures the Anarchy sisters Garterbelt is making them dinner because he is trying to show them his appreciation after doing a job well done. All the angels' orders arrive, as well as Garterbelt bringing them all the food he had been cooking, and orders them to not leave a single crumb behind. In the end, the angels eat everything and begin to feel bloated. They decide not to go to the club on account of they won't be able to fit in the VIP. Instead they watch T.V. and Panty again ask Stocking if she plans to sleep with the guy she made out with yesterday.