The episode starts with a narrator, who explains siblings fight very often, and that even though they may look alike on the outside, they have completely different opinions, if not opposites. He also assures that the closer they are, the more often they fight. The setting changes to that of the church's front, where Stocking is seen searching frenetically for her pudding.
Stocking tells Panty her missing pudding was very special, for it had a 500-year waiting list. Stocking soon finds out Panty was the one who ate her pudding. Now completely enraged, Stocking lectures Panty on how she is very irresponsible and always leaves a mess wherever she goes. Panty tries fixing things by offering Stocking her Death-Babanero chips, but Stocking denies them. Panty, annoyed, tells Stocking that if she keeps eating too many sweets, she is going to get fat. But Stocking retorts saying all the fat goes towards her boobs.
Their argument escalates to the point where they eventually point their weapons at each other, but Garterbelt and Brief arrive just in time to stop them from going any further. Garterbelt tells both Anarchy sisters Heaven sent him a clue to a ghost's whereabouts, but Panty and Stocking, not wanting to work together, decide to go search for the ghost on their own, and leave with Brief and Chuck respectively. Panty starts giving Brief sexual innuendo nicknames, while Stocking steals See Through, rolling Brief over in the process.
Upon arriving where the ghost was supposed to be, Stocking encounters a little girl with a red hood. The girl tells her a wolf attacked her recently, and Stocking, believing it had to be the ghost in disguise, asks the girl to take her where the wolf was. The girl leads Stocking to a lonely alley, where the ghost appears and attacks them both. But Stocking, not knowing the girl was also part of said ghost, is easily restrained with a rope by them. Panty, along with Brief, arrives and free Stocking out of the rope.
Panty and Stocking start arguing all over again, and are not really paying attention to the ghosts anymore. Annoyed, both ghosts attack them, and upon defeating the Anarchy sisters, they begin to insult them, which results in the angels' rage. Panty and Stocking finally decide to work together once again, in order to kill the ghosts, who explode, leaving two Heaven Coins behind. Panty offers Brief a ride home, but Garterbelt interferes, assuring he is going to take Brief home on his own. While driving home, Panty gifts Stocking a spicy version of Jean-Paul Heaven, which Stocking accepts with a smile, despite not liking spicy food.